Former Russian president calls Ukraine 'a disappearing country' and notes 'Trump's ratings have gone down'

The United States and Ukraine have struck a significant agreement, establishing a fund that will receive 50% of royalties and fees from Ukraine's natural resource projects. This deal is part of a broader strategy to foster long-term cooperation, with the US potentially offering additional assistance such as air defense systems. While this development indicates a strengthening of US-Ukraine ties, it raises questions about the US's stance on brokering peace in the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict.
In response to this development, Russian Security Council Deputy Chair Dmitry Medvedev criticized former President Donald Trump, suggesting that Trump's influence is waning and highlighting tensions with the US, particularly regarding impending sanctions. The narrative reflects the complex geopolitical dynamics at play, with the US navigating its role in the conflict, balancing support for Ukraine, and managing its relationship with Russia amidst internal political pressures.
RATING
The article covers significant geopolitical issues involving the U.S., Ukraine, and Russia, focusing on a minerals deal and Medvedev's statements. While it provides a clear and timely overview of these topics, it lacks depth in terms of diverse perspectives and comprehensive analysis. The reliance on a limited range of sources and the absence of detailed verification for some claims affect its accuracy and balance. Enhancing source diversity and transparency would improve the article's reliability and impact. Despite these limitations, the article effectively highlights important international developments of public interest.
RATING DETAILS
The story presents several claims that require verification, such as Medvedev's statement about Ukraine being a 'disappearing country' and the specifics of the U.S.-Ukraine minerals deal. While the article does quote Medvedev and provides some context about the minerals deal, it lacks detailed verification of these claims. For instance, the article does not provide independent confirmation of the economic or political implications of the deal between the U.S. and Ukraine. Additionally, the claim about Trump's declining ratings is supported by a Fox News poll, but the article could benefit from a broader range of sources to substantiate this point.
The article primarily presents the perspective of Russian official Dmitry Medvedev and the U.S. government, with limited input from Ukrainian officials. While it mentions Yulia Svyrydenko's comments on the deal, it does not provide a comprehensive view from Ukrainian stakeholders or independent analysts. This creates an imbalance, as the Russian perspective is more prominently featured, potentially skewing the reader's understanding of the situation. Including a wider range of viewpoints, particularly from Ukrainian sources, would enhance the article's balance.
The article is generally clear in its presentation of information, using straightforward language and a logical structure. It effectively conveys the key points of Medvedev's statements and the U.S.-Ukraine minerals deal. However, the article could benefit from more detailed explanations of complex topics, such as the economic and political implications of the deal, to enhance reader comprehension. Providing additional context would help readers better understand the significance of the claims presented.
The article relies on statements from Dmitry Medvedev and a Fox News poll, which are credible sources for their respective claims. However, the article could improve its source quality by incorporating a broader array of perspectives, such as expert analysis or commentary from independent political analysts. This would provide a more nuanced understanding of the implications of the U.S.-Ukraine deal and the political dynamics in the U.S. and Russia.
The article provides limited transparency regarding the basis for its claims. While it quotes Medvedev and references a Fox News poll, it does not delve into the methodology behind these sources or explore potential biases. Additionally, the article does not clearly explain the context or significance of the U.S.-Ukraine minerals deal, leaving readers without a full understanding of the situation. Greater transparency about the sources and their potential biases would improve the article's credibility.
Sources
- https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2025/05/01/medvedev-warns-of-vanishing-ukraine-after-us-signs-minerals-deal-with-kyiv-a88945
- https://wfin.com/fox-political-news/former-russian-president-calls-ukraine-a-disappearing-country-and-notes-trumps-ratings-have-gone-down/
- https://www.nationalreview.com/news/russia-mocks-mineral-resources-deal-claims-ukraine-will-disappear/
- https://www.dailywire.com/news/russia-hits-u-s-over-minerals-deal-says-ukraine-is-about-to-disappear
- https://abcnews.go.com/International/ukraine-russia-react-controversial-us-minerals-sharing-deal/story?id=121347233
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

A ‘historic economic partnership?’ What we know about Trump’s Ukraine mineral deal
Score 6.0
US-Ukraine inching toward mineral deal amid last-minute roadblocks
Score 6.8
'We have never been this close to peace' since Russia invaded Ukraine, Leavitt tells reporters
Score 5.4
Trump Threatens Sanctions And Tariffs On Russia To End War—But Says Moscow May Be ‘Easier’ To Deal With Than Ukraine
Score 5.2