Head of Brazil's gas giant Petrobras criticized for 'drill, baby, drill!' comment about the Amazon

Yahoo! News - May 9th, 2025
Open on Yahoo! News

Magda Chambriard, head of Brazil's Petrobras, is facing backlash after a video showed her using the phrase "Drill, baby, drill!" at a conference in Houston, referring to the company's controversial oil exploration plans near the Amazon River's mouth. The comments, made to Amapa's governor Clécio Luís, have sparked criticism given the environmental sensitivity of the region and the global push to curb fossil fuel use. Petrobras confirmed the video's authenticity but did not comment further.

The incident highlights the tension between economic interests and environmental concerns in Brazil, especially under President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's administration. While Lula has made strides in reducing deforestation and promoting climate initiatives, his support for Petrobras's drilling plans has drawn scrutiny. As the COP30 climate summit, to be hosted in the Amazonian city of Belem, approaches, these actions may face increased scrutiny, potentially impacting Brazil's environmental credibility on the global stage.

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

7.6
Fair Story
Consider it well-founded

The article provides a well-rounded and timely examination of the controversial Petrobras drilling project near the Amazon River. It effectively balances the perspectives of corporate interests and environmental concerns, supported by credible sources and clear writing. While the story is largely accurate and engages with important public interest topics, it could benefit from additional source diversity and deeper exploration of opposing viewpoints. The article's potential to influence public discourse and policy discussions is significant, particularly in the context of the upcoming COP30 climate summit. Overall, the story succeeds in presenting a complex issue in an accessible and engaging manner, though there is room for improvement in transparency and source variety.

RATING DETAILS

8
Accuracy

The story is largely accurate, as it reports on Magda Chambriard's remarks during the Offshore Technology Conference, which aligns with the factual events described. The authenticity of the video is confirmed by Petrobras, and the context of the remarks, including the applause from Governor Clécio Luís, is consistent with verified details. However, the article could improve by providing more evidence or direct quotes from the involved parties, such as Petrobras's official stance or comments from environmental groups. The article accurately ties the phrase 'Drill, baby, drill!' to U.S. President Donald Trump, providing historical context to its usage. While the story correctly outlines the potential climate implications and political dynamics, it would benefit from additional data or studies to substantiate claims about environmental impacts and climate change.

7
Balance

The article presents a balanced view by including both the perspective of Petrobras and the criticism from environmentalists. It mentions the support from President Lula, highlighting his mixed environmental record, which adds depth to the narrative. However, the story could enhance balance by including more diverse viewpoints, such as those from Indigenous communities or local residents who might be affected by the drilling. The inclusion of a quote from a climate policy think tank provides a critical perspective, but the article could further explore the arguments of those supporting the project beyond the corporate interests of Petrobras.

8
Clarity

The article is clearly written, with a logical structure that guides the reader through the events and implications of the drilling project. The language is straightforward, and the tone is neutral, making the content accessible to a broad audience. The use of direct quotes and historical context, such as the reference to Donald Trump, enhances comprehension. However, the article could improve clarity by providing more detailed explanations of technical terms, such as the 'environmental license,' to ensure all readers fully understand the implications.

8
Source quality

The story relies on credible sources, such as the Brazilian newspaper Valor Economico and statements from recognized figures like Magda Chambriard and Natalie Unterstell. The Associated Press is a reputable news organization, which adds credibility to the reporting. However, the article could improve by citing additional sources, such as environmental reports or statements from Petrobras or government officials, to provide a more comprehensive view. The reliance on a single video and a few quotes limits the depth of source variety, though the existing sources are authoritative and relevant.

7
Transparency

The article is transparent about its sources, mentioning the video obtained by Valor Economico and confirming its authenticity through Petrobras. It also discloses the financial support for AP's climate and environmental coverage, which is commendable. However, the story could improve transparency by providing more context on the methodology of obtaining the video and any potential conflicts of interest from the quoted sources. The article does not explain the basis for some claims, such as the expected scrutiny during COP30, which could be clarified with additional context.

Sources

  1. https://valorinternational.globo.com/business/news/2025/05/07/petrobras-ceo-piles-on-pressure-for-equatorial-margin-drilling.ghtml
  2. https://news.mongabay.com/2025/02/lula-pushes-oil-drilling-at-mouth-of-amazon-despite-climate-risks/