Pope Leo XIV Explains His Name Choice—Here's What He Told Cardinals

Forbes - May 10th, 2025

Pope Leo XIV, formerly known as Robert Francis Prevost, explained his choice of papal name, emphasizing his commitment to continuing the legacy of Pope Leo XIII, who was renowned for advocating workers' rights and fair wages during the late 19th century. By choosing the name Leo XIV, the new pope signals his intention to prioritize social justice and labor issues, particularly in the face of modern challenges such as the potential for artificial intelligence to displace human jobs. His remarks come shortly after being voted in as pope on May 8, following the death of Pope Francis.

As the first American pope with Creole and Haitian roots, Leo XIV brings a diverse background to the papacy. His election has been met with interest regarding how he will navigate contemporary social issues. The new pope's commitment to building an inclusive church resonates with his predecessor's focus on aiding the disenfranchised. By drawing upon the values of past pontiffs like Leo XIII and Leo I, known for their diplomatic and social justice efforts, Pope Leo XIV is poised to address both traditional church teachings and the evolving challenges of the modern world.

Artificial Intelligence Catholic Church Workers' Rights Social Justice Papal Conclave Pope Leo Xiv Pope Leo Xiii

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

6.0

Moderately Fair

Read with skepticism

The article provides a timely and generally clear overview of Pope Leo XIV's election and his alignment with historical values of social justice. It effectively highlights the significance of his name choice and potential implications for the Catholic Church's direction. However, the story lacks diverse perspectives and detailed sourcing, which affects its balance and source quality. While it touches on important issues like artificial intelligence and labor, the analysis remains surface-level, limiting its impact and engagement potential. Despite these limitations, the article remains relevant and of interest to audiences concerned with religious leadership and socio-economic challenges.

Accuracy

The story claims that Pope Leo XIV chose his name to align with Pope Leo XIII's values, which is consistent with historical context regarding Pope Leo XIII's advocacy for workers' rights. However, the specifics of Pope Leo XIV's intentions and policies, particularly regarding artificial intelligence, are speculative without direct quotes or official statements. The article accurately states Pope Leo XIV's election date and his background as the first American pope, but the mention of his voting in U.S. elections is unusual and requires verification. Overall, while the historical references are accurate, some claims about Pope Leo XIV's future actions and policies need further substantiation.

Balance

The article primarily presents the perspective of Pope Leo XIV and his alignment with Pope Leo XIII's values. It briefly mentions the views of Rev. Art Purcaro and a family member, providing limited external perspectives. However, it lacks a diverse range of viewpoints, such as those from church officials or critics, which could offer a more balanced understanding of the new pope's potential impact and policies. The focus on the pope's name choice and its significance might overshadow other important aspects of his papacy.

Clarity

The article is generally clear and well-structured, with a logical flow from the introduction of Pope Leo XIV's name choice to the exploration of his background and potential policies. The language is straightforward, making the content accessible to a general audience. However, the inclusion of various topics, such as artificial intelligence and voting history, without clear transitions, might confuse readers about the article's main focus. Overall, the clarity of presentation is strong, with minor areas for improvement in coherence.

Source quality

The article references statements from Pope Leo XIV, Rev. Art Purcaro, and a family member, but it lacks citations from authoritative sources like the Vatican or official church documents. The reliance on secondary sources, such as comments to CNN, without direct quotes or official statements, raises questions about the reliability of the information. The use of a Getty Images photo credit suggests some level of professional journalism, but the absence of direct sourcing weakens the overall credibility.

Transparency

The article does not clearly disclose the sources of its information or the methodology behind its claims, particularly regarding Pope Leo XIV's views on artificial intelligence and his voting history. There is no discussion of potential conflicts of interest or how the information was obtained. The lack of transparency in sourcing and methodology makes it difficult for readers to assess the basis of the claims and understand the context behind the story.