Trump claims 'I don't know her' and 'listened to' RFK Jr about surgeon general pick getting MAGA pushback

President Donald Trump has nominated Dr. Casey Means as the new U.S. Surgeon General, relying on the recommendation of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. This decision follows the withdrawal of Trump's initial nominee, Dr. Janette Nesheiwat. Dr. Casey Means, noted for her advocacy of the 'Make America Healthy Again' (MAHA) initiative, is recognized for her contributions to the administration's health agenda alongside her brother, Calley Means. Trump's choice underscores the administration’s continuing focus on health and wellness, reflected in Means' background as a wellness influencer and co-founder of a health-tech firm.
The nomination of Dr. Means is part of broader strategic changes within the Trump administration, aligning with its health priorities. This move coincides with Kennedy's plan to phase out artificial food dyes, marking a shift towards a more health-conscious policy framework. The withdrawal of Nesheiwat and her subsequent focus on supporting Trump in a senior policy role further highlights the administration's internal realignments. Meanwhile, Nesheiwat's connection with Michael Waltz, the newly nominated U.N. ambassador, points to ongoing reshuffles in Trump’s team as he prepares for future political endeavors.
RATING
The article provides a timely and relevant overview of the nomination of Dr. Casey Means as the U.S. surgeon general, highlighting the roles of President Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. It effectively captures public interest by focusing on a significant political and health policy issue. However, the story could be improved by incorporating a wider range of perspectives and more detailed attributions to enhance balance and source quality. Additionally, greater transparency regarding the basis of certain claims would increase the article's credibility. Overall, while the article is clear and accessible, it would benefit from a more comprehensive exploration of the topic to fully engage and inform its audience.
RATING DETAILS
The story presents several facts that align with known details, such as the nomination of Dr. Casey Means for U.S. surgeon general and the withdrawal of Dr. Janette Nesheiwat's nomination. It accurately reports President Trump's reliance on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s recommendation for Dr. Means' nomination. However, some claims need further verification, such as the specific reasons for Nesheiwat's withdrawal and the exact nature of Dr. Means' credentials and influence within the administration. The story mentions Dr. Means' background and her brother's role, which are consistent with other reports, but it lacks direct citations to authoritative sources, which could strengthen its factual basis.
The article primarily focuses on President Trump's decision-making process and the roles of Dr. Casey Means and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., with less emphasis on other perspectives. It does not provide views from other stakeholders, such as Dr. Nesheiwat or independent experts on the implications of these nominations. The narrative is somewhat one-sided, highlighting the administration's perspective without exploring potential criticisms or alternative viewpoints, which could provide a more balanced understanding of the situation.
The article is generally clear in its language and structure, presenting the main events in a straightforward manner. However, it could improve in coherence, as it jumps between different topics, such as the nomination process and background information on Dr. Means, without smooth transitions. Additionally, the use of terms like 'MAHA credentials' without explanation might confuse readers unfamiliar with the context. A more organized presentation of facts and definitions of key terms would enhance clarity.
The article references prominent figures like President Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., but lacks direct quotes or detailed attributions from these individuals or their representatives. The story does not cite independent sources or expert opinions that could add depth and credibility. The reliance on a single media outlet (Fox News) raises questions about potential bias, and the absence of diverse sources limits the article's reliability and comprehensiveness.
The article does not clearly disclose the methodology used to gather information, nor does it explain the potential conflicts of interest that might affect the reporting. There is a lack of transparency regarding the basis for certain claims, such as the rationale behind Dr. Nesheiwat's withdrawal. The story could benefit from more explicit disclosures about its sources and the context surrounding the reported events to enhance reader understanding and trust.
Sources
- https://www.politico.com/news/2025/05/07/trump-surgeon-general-casey-means-00334304
- https://www.aha.org/news/headline/2025-05-08-trump-nominates-casey-means-surgeon-general
- https://people.com/who-is-casey-means-11730726
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JeuD0RTuDZk
- https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-nominates-dr-casey-means-wellness-influencer-close-to-rfk-jr-for-surgeon-general
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

What We Know About Casey Means—Trump’s New Nomination For Surgeon General
Score 6.8
Kennedy defends new surgeon general pick from MAGA backlash
Score 6.2
Trump picks Casey Means for surgeon general, after first nominee withdraws
Score 5.4
Meet the L.A. holistic doctor and wellness influencer who is Trump's choice for surgeon general
Score 7.2