Trump Fired Copyright Chief After She Warned Of AI Companies Violating The Law

The Trump administration has sparked controversy by firing Shira Perlmutter, the head of the U.S. Copyright Office, following her office's report condemning AI companies for using copyrighted content without consent. The report criticized AI firms for leveraging copyrighted works illegally to create competitive content, challenging fair use boundaries. Perlmutter's removal, along with the firing of Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden, has been met with backlash, as both positions are under Congress's oversight rather than the President's. Trump appointed Todd Blanche, lacking relevant experience, to lead the Library of Congress.
The firings have raised suspicions of political influence, particularly concerning Elon Musk's interests in AI. Congressman Joe Morelle linked the dismissals to Perlmutter's refusal to approve Musk's data mining activities. The incident underscores ongoing concerns about AI companies like OpenAI, Meta, and Musk's xAI, which face accusations of copyright violations. This development highlights the tensions between AI advancements and intellectual property rights, with significant legal and ethical implications for the tech industry and content creators.
RATING
The article presents a timely and engaging topic, focusing on the intersection of politics, technology, and law. While the main claims about the firings and the AI copyright report are accurate, the story includes several unverified details and lacks balance in perspective. The absence of direct sources and transparency about the author's methodology affects the story's credibility. Despite these weaknesses, the article effectively highlights significant public interest issues, such as the ethical use of AI and the limits of executive power. To enhance its impact and engagement, the story could benefit from more balanced viewpoints and clearer source attribution.
RATING DETAILS
The story contains several accurate claims, such as the firing of Shira Perlmutter and the context of the AI copyright report. These are confirmed by multiple reputable sources. However, some details, like Trump's personal reaction and the appointment of Todd Blanche, lack sufficient verification. The claim about the OpenAI whistleblower's death and specific allegations against AI companies need further evidence. The story presents a mix of verified and unverified information, leading to a moderate accuracy score.
The article presents a critical view of the Trump administration's actions, focusing on the potential illegality of the firings and the implications for AI companies. While it includes reactions from Democratic lawmakers, it lacks perspectives from the Trump administration or supporters. This imbalance suggests a bias towards a particular narrative, potentially omitting important viewpoints.
The article is generally clear and concise, with a logical flow that guides the reader through the main events. However, the inclusion of unverified claims and a lack of context in certain areas may confuse readers. The language is straightforward, but the narrative could benefit from additional context and explanation of complex issues.
The story references known entities like the U.S. Copyright Office and mentions statements from Democratic lawmakers. However, it lacks direct attribution to primary sources or official statements, relying instead on indirect references. The absence of diverse sources and direct quotes affects the story's credibility and reliability.
The article does not clearly disclose its sources or methodology, making it difficult for readers to assess the basis of its claims. It lacks transparency regarding potential conflicts of interest or the author's perspective. This lack of disclosure diminishes the article's credibility and leaves readers questioning the impartiality of the information presented.
Sources
- https://fortune.com/2025/05/12/donald-trump-copyright-director-ai-companies-training-elon-musk-shira-perlmutter/
- https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-admin-fires-top-us-copyright-official-days-after-terminating-librarian-congress
- https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2025-05-11/trump-administration-fires-top-copyright-official-days-after-firing-librarian-of-congress
- https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-fires-director-of-u-s-copyright-office-shira-perlmutter-sources/
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Trump admin fires top US copyright official days after terminating Librarian of Congress
Score 6.8
Trump has fired the director of the US Copyright Office
Score 6.2
Microsoft to lay off 3% of global workforce — roughly 7K jobs — in shift to develop AI
Score 7.6
The US Copyright Office has thoughts on how AI is trained. Big Tech may not like it.
Score 6.0