Why It Would Be Really Dumb for the Oscars Not to Nominate ‘Challengers’ for Best Picture

Variety - Dec 18th, 2024

The article questions whether the film 'Challengers,' a mid-budget drama directed by Luca Guadagnino, will be nominated for Best Picture at the Academy Awards. The author argues that such films, once central to the Oscars, are now sidelined in favor of blockbuster hits or niche art films. 'Challengers' is praised for its writing, direction, cinematography, and acting, and has been successful at the box office. Despite its qualities, it risks being overlooked due to the Oscars' current trend of favoring either mega-blockbusters or art films with limited audiences. The author believes that acknowledging films like 'Challengers' is crucial for the film industry to honor and encourage movies that are both smart and entertaining.

Challengers Academy Awards Oscars Luca Guadagnino Film Industry Mid Budget Drama

Story submitted by Fairstory

RATING

5.0

Moderately Fair

Read with skepticism

The article is a subjective opinion piece discussing the potential for the film 'Challengers' to receive an Oscar nomination. It raises concerns about the current state of the Academy Awards and the types of films they tend to honor. While the piece is written with a clear perspective, it lacks the depth of factual reporting and relies heavily on personal opinion.

Accuracy

The article is largely opinion-based with limited factual content. It mentions potential Oscar nominations and box office figures but does not provide specific sources for these claims.

Balance

The article presents a strong bias in favor of 'Challengers' and against what it perceives as the Oscars' preference for certain types of films. It does not offer counterarguments or alternative perspectives.

Clarity

The article is clearly written and easy to follow, with a coherent argument. However, the tone is subjective and somewhat emotive, reflecting the author's strong opinions.

Source quality

There are no explicit sources cited in the article to support its claims about the Oscars or the box office performance of 'Challengers.' The arguments are primarily based on the author's viewpoint.

Transparency

The author discloses personal bias as a 'superfan' of 'Challengers,' which adds transparency about the perspective taken. However, there is no disclosure of potential conflicts of interest.